Funny thing is, I can look back at certain periods of my life and remember what my favorites were at that time. For instance Hepcat was my favorite band while I was a senior in high school and until I was about 24 or 25.
That's not to say they got crossed off the list, they just stopped producing music, and I stopped listening. I still love it, its just not my favorite today, but I am not even sure what my favorite is today.
Here is the problem I have and it spans in to many aspects of my belief system. I may like something but I reserve the right to dislike it at a later date. I wasnt always granted that right throughout my life. For example in middle school I was faced with the decision that I was either going to like Rap, Soul and R&B and be a part of the "soulers", or I was going to like new wave and alternative music and be a "new waver". Trust me liking country was not even an option. I could have chosen rock, but then I would have been a "stoner". Like so many white suburbanite kids I chose new wave, and I had to stick to it, at least till my Junior or Senior year. I remember my tape and CD collection being limited to bands like A-ha (my first tape) and PetShopBoys (my first CD, I paid like $35 for it). Erasure was always a favorite but I had to be a closet listener since likeing a gay pop star was about the same as being a gay pop star. That was logical though cause if you liked Bobby Brown, you had to like sex, it was your perogative. I digress...
Back to Hepcat. I was introduced to Hepcat by being brought to a live show they performed at in San Diego at SOMA, back when it was in the downtown area (South Of Market Avenue, hence SOMA) this was in the spring of 1992. They were incredible and I couldnt believe they sounded the way they did, it was like listening to Desmond Decker on vinyl or even better the Skatalites. I went to every show they performed at in the area and constantly listened to the tapes I had. I was living in Provo, Utah the summer of 94 and they managed somehow to make Provo a tour stop. I remember being so stoked on them coming to a small venue and even meeting with the band and chatting with them in between sets. I distincly remember liking a pair of shoes worn by the front man Deston Berry and I went out later that week and got a pair (Adidas Sambas, way comfy and semi stylish). They finally got a nice break and had a somewhat successful CD release in 1997 the Right on Time album. I got a copy and listened constantly, it was so good. Then one day I was cleaning out my boss's garage and I came across the cd in a tool bag or something. I put it aside and asked him about it. I can remember the conversation to this day. It went something like this:
ME: "Is this your CD"
Boss: "Yeah"
Me: "You like them"
Boss: "meeeh... so-so"
Me: "so-so?"
Boss: "yeah some of it is nice but a lot of it is like really bad jazz"
Me: (trying to retain composure)"oh"
So I thought about that for a while. and later I asked him
Me: "How did you hear about these guys?"
Boss: "I saw them on TV."
I didnt know what to think. I was happy to hear that a band I liked for so many years that was hard working and creative and truly talented was getting a break, but at the same time sad. I can only think of selfish reasons for having been sad. I guess was bummed that the shows would be sold out now and would be attended by people my parents age. I was worried that maybe the sound would become pop-ish. Or band members would get jaded and cockey. I was worried that the world would change my band. All my memories and experiences would be relegated to being a fan of a pop band. Kinda like nobody cares if you are a Beatles fan, even in the early years, cause shoot everyone was. Funny thing is Hepcat never really went bigger than that album, and even though one of the band members Alex Désert got some nice acting gigs and even a main role on a prime time sitcom, they never got big heads. Apparently they still spring up and play a gig (albeit the price for admission has gone from $5 to $40) and they even have a myspace page. wee.
I don't know if I learned a lesson through this or if I became more of an adult. I do remember not having picked a favorite band since then.